
James Bond Eggs
1. I started taking claims earlier sure yeah, you could call it scummy, but I was just trying to figure out who to target, especially since the reads here are terrible
2.I just didn’t think of it at the time. I could lie and deceive if I wanted to, but I’m working with mechanically confirmed town players and they trust me. You don’t have to believe me, but that’s the situation as it is.
If I messed up I apologize. My claim might not be perfect, but you can’t deny that town is in chaos right now.
Two people are claiming Huntress, and we're not making progress. So yeah, maybe my claim isn’t the best, but from my perspective, even if I die, the most important thing is to establish everything clearly.
I’ve been playing Mafia for a while, and I’m good at reading people. I started just two months ago, but I’m not hiding the fact that I’m not bad at and acting clueless. I trust myself, and if you don’t trust me, that’s fine. But you’re likely to be marked as untrusted, eliminated or lynched eventually if you can’t mech prove yourself. If I’ve already gathered 14 claims, town is in trouble either way. If you’re town, you’ll see that too. If you don’t want to believe me, that’s your choice, but that’s all I’ve got.
Of course, I’ll push and make threats to show I’m serious, not just roleplaying. I realize I may have made a mistake and that I could die soon, but I’m just trying to help town as much as I can.
1) The main issue I have with that is that you claim to have 14 claims in a 17 person game, yet you only claimed like 2:30 before you said such. I think that was just a direct lie to try to strongarm people into claiming for the reason i said before of "it is already cooked."
2) I can understand that, I don't think you are 100% a wolf I just think it is likely you are a wolf and not a risk worth taking, because I think you are creative enough of a player to go for that play. Mechanically confirmed town bit, fair but I can't know that myself, unfortunately.
If you are really assassin, I think it is good if you get some claims, just in my eyes it isn't worth gambling on you being assassin to give you the entire claims list. I agree town is in chaos, and I get wanting to do something like this as a townie, I just feel like the risks outweigh the good.
Yeah, I get how this could be a town play, I just also get how it could be a scum play and don't like the fact that I now think you are lying about the amount of claims you have and possibly your knowledge on TP. Since you are experienced in mafia I feel like you are a player who would read up on things like that before claiming. I also get the "I trust myself" mentality because I do the same thing, whether you are town or scum this feels like a play I would try to do to sneak some info into my pockets, because I will go for info no matter my alignment typically.
TL;DR I get it and I see how this play could happen from either alignment, I just think that because of who it specifically is (dedicated mafia player) it is more likely a scum play due to the fact I think they would read up on these things and they can use their newbie status for free points. I also highly doubt the claim about getting 14/17 claims that quickly because I know from experience that does not really happen here.