The Reaper wins when all players are dead, unaligned, sleepless or nightmare-aligned. For each player that dies, the Reaper may use a power to turn another player sleepless.

The Reaper starts out sleepless and shares a channel with other members of the nightmare team. At the start of every night, the Reaper will be informed of which powers they may use that night. These powers correspond to the role categories of the players who have died since the start of the previous night. Each power is immediate, and turns its target sleepless: some powers have an additional effect, applied to the same target. For Killing roles the additional effect is an attack; for Investigative roles it is a role investigation; for Recruitment and Align roles it turns the target into a spirit. All other role categories have no additional effect. The Reaper is not told which role category the dead players belonged to: they are only informed of which powers (kills, investigations, conversions, and basic powers) are available to them. If the Reaper chooses not to use one of their powers during the night, they may not then use it the next night.

Sleepless players are not informed of their being sleepless: however, if a sleepless player uses an ability other than targeting on the Reaper, their ability fails and the Reaper immediately attacks them. The Reaper is affected by all disguises, obstructions and redirections when using their powers. They gain powers solely based on the true roles of those who have died. If no members of the nightmare team or channel remain, the sleepless effect is silently removed from all players.

At the start of the game, the Psychopath is given an arbitrary list with one third of the town’s population, rounded up, on it. If all players on that list are dead, and the Psychopath is still alive, the Psychopath wins.

When the Psychopath wins, the Psychopath ascends and stops playing. The game continues. The Psychopath can’t win when they are dead. The Psychopath's list will always contain at least one player from every team that has at least two players. The Psychopath may strongly disguise themself as any role. The disguise is applied immediately. They can update this disguise once per phase, with 1 emergency change to be used whenever the Psychopath wants to. If the Psychopath changes role, the disguise is lost. Additionally, the Psychopath may choose to either investigate or weakly disguise a player each day, but not both. Their investigation is affected by all disguises, redirections and obstructions. Their disguise lasts for the current and next phase.